Verse 1
I'm reminded of the summer
when I dated Sarah Plummer
in that Indiana town where we both lived 
she was a 10 sent down from Heaven 
on a good day I'm a 7
but that didn't seem to bother her a bit

Verse 2
When she took me by the hand 
It made me feel like a grown man 
heady stuff for a hayseed such as me 
I guess she taught me how to love 
and when push comes down to shove 
ain't that how it's all supposed to be?

Chorus
I guess most of us will have a Sarah Plummer 
who comes along and helps us to discover 
all the things that people write about in songs 
the kinds of things that: we knew all along

Verse 3
I ran into her today
and felt the years just melt away
time hasn't done a thing to dull her shine
I felt the passion start to rise
when I looked into her eyes
but I knew it was too late to make her mine

Verse 4
With her two precious little kids
and her hand now holding his
it did me good just to see her smile
We talked awhile and shared some laughs 
and reminisced about the past
now I'll hold on to this memory for awhile

Bridge
Our paths diverged so long ago
and we went down our separate roads
but we kept little memories for the trip 
She preferred the family life
I took  a different script

Chorus
I guess most of us will have a Sarah Plummer 
who comes along and helps us to discover 
all the things that people write about in songs 
the kinds of things that we knew all along